SmallBizGenius Analysis

Florsheim, a long-standing brand for men's dress shoes, receives mixed feedback regarding its online service and product quality. While some customers remain loyal to the brand, many report issues with online orders, returns, and sizing inconsistencies.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 14 recent reviews

Returns & Refunds

2.5/10

Customers frequently complain about difficult and costly return processes. Many reviewers mention unexpected return shipping fees and delays in receiving refunds, with one stating it took "a month to return the shoes to my credit card."

7 reviews mention this

Sizing & Fit

3.0/10

Several reviewers report issues with inconsistent sizing, particularly when ordering online. Customers describe receiving shoes that are either too large or too small despite ordering their usual size, leading to frustration and the need for returns, as one reviewer noted "one pair too big and the other too small."

5 reviews mention this

Product Quality

4.0/10

Some customers express disappointment with the quality of Florsheim shoes, especially compared to their past experiences with the brand. Reviewers cite issues like defects, shoes appearing used, and soles crumbling after light use, with one customer saying, "Material was not flexible, no arch support and the shoe was too long."

6 reviews mention this

Customer Service

4.5/10

Customer service experiences are mixed, with some reviewers praising individual representatives while others report unresponsiveness and rudeness. Some customers express frustration with the lack of assistance in resolving issues, as one reviewer stated the customer service was "pretty rude instead of making it right."

5 reviews mention this

Shipping & Order Accuracy

2.0/10

Several customers report issues with order accuracy, including receiving the wrong color or model of shoes. Additionally, some reviewers experienced problems with incorrect shipping addresses, leading to delays and inconvenience, such as one reviewer noting the shoes were sent to the "Wrong Address: Despite clearly specifying my shipping address, they sent the shoes to my billing address."

4 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Good footwear selection in physical stores. Mentioned 2x
"Great footwear selection and amazing customer service!"
Helpful staff in some physical locations. Mentioned 2x
"the shop attendant, Tracy, went above and beyond to find a great pair of shoes for me."
Satisfied with online purchase. Mentioned 1x
"Completely Satisfied."

Common Complaints

Unexpected return shipping fees. Mentioned 2x
"They actually charge me $12 and the cost of a plastic envelope was $6 for a total of $18 to try on a pair of shoes"
Inconsistent sizing in online orders. Mentioned 3x
"Yet one pair too big and the other too small."
Poor online customer service responsiveness. Mentioned 2x
"I called customer service and sent them an email with no response to either."
Product quality not as good as it used to be. Mentioned 2x
"NOT what they used to be."
Orders shipped to wrong address. Mentioned 1x
"Despite clearly specifying my shipping address, they sent the shoes to my billing address."

Common Questions About Florsheims

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Florsheims legit and trustworthy?

Florsheim is a long-standing brand, but recent reviews suggest caution when ordering online. While some customers remain loyal, others report issues with order accuracy, sizing, and returns. The trustworthiness of their online service is questionable, with multiple reviewers citing unexpected fees and poor customer service experiences. It's advisable to proceed with caution and consider purchasing in-store to ensure a satisfactory experience.

Based on 7 reviews

Does Florsheims have good customer service?

Customer service experiences with Florsheim appear to be inconsistent. Some reviewers praise the helpfulness of individual representatives in physical stores, while others report unresponsiveness and rudeness from online customer service. The lack of consistent support and difficulty in resolving issues contribute to a negative perception of their customer service. Customers should be prepared for potential challenges when seeking assistance with online orders.

Based on 5 reviews

Is Florsheims worth it for small business?

For small businesses, the value proposition of Florsheim is questionable due to reported issues with online orders and inconsistent quality. The risk of receiving incorrect sizes, defective products, or encountering difficulties with returns may outweigh the benefits of purchasing from the brand. Small businesses should carefully weigh these potential drawbacks and consider alternative brands with more reliable online services and consistent product quality.

Based on 4 reviews

What is Florsheims' return policy like?

Florsheim's return policy is a point of contention for many customers. Several reviewers report unexpected return shipping fees, which can be as high as $20. Additionally, some customers experienced delays in receiving refunds and difficulties in getting their returns processed. The return policy's lack of clarity and potential for unexpected costs make it a significant concern for online shoppers.

Based on 7 reviews

Why are Florsheim shoe sizes inconsistent online?

The inconsistency in Florsheim shoe sizes online is a recurring issue reported by customers. Some reviewers speculate that the company may be selling flawed or irregular items online. Regardless of the reason, the sizing discrepancies lead to frustration and the need for returns, making it difficult for customers to confidently purchase shoes online without trying them on first.

Based on 3 reviews